Drying is the most energy-intensive process in the papermaking process accounting for 80% of thermal energy costs due principally to cylinder drying and supply air heating. Drying energy consumption depends on many factors such as press design concept, steam and condensate system optimization, hood air balance and exhaust humidity control. This article looks at the latter two factors, namely the optimization of the paper machine hood and air systems.
[A free webinar for papermakers discussed this topic in depth on September 23rd. Click HERE to view the recorded webinar.]
Just looking at the tons of steam consumed per ton of paper produced (tsteam/tproduction) doesn’t correctly rate the efficiency of the drying process. A more complete and realistic evaluation is the steam consumption per ton of water evaporated: tsteam/tevaporated H2O. For example, air balance of the papermachine hood has a significant impact on steam consumption at the drying cylinders, if we consider that all air flow through the dryer section is heated up to exhaust air temperature, including the cold, ambient leakage air that infiltrates into the hood; this air is also being heated by the dryer cylinders, in turn consuming steam. The graph below shows the impact of leakage air on dryer section ventilation and the related annual energy cost:
As a case example, let's consider a hood operation where all exhaust controls are 100% open. The evaporated water would then be exhausted from the dryer section with an average air humidity of 109 g H2O/kg d.a (or 0.1090 lb/lb = 763 grains) versus the original exhaust load for which the hood was designed, being 160 g H2O/kg d.a. (or 0.1600 lb/lb = 1120 grains).
As a result, to maintain this lower exhaust load there would be additional leakage air required of 57 kg d.a/s which in turn would also be heated by the dryer cylinders. The increase in steam consumption would be 2.8 MW or 4.9 t steam/h which would represent 7.3% of the drying section’s steam consumption.
There are also electrical savings possible by improving air balance. Small changes in air flow can result in important changes in required fan power. Since fan power is in relation to air flow (rotation speed) to the power of three, then as an example, a 10% reduction in air flow would save 27% in electrical cost.
Therefore, to maintain good energy efficiency the use of an air balance control is recommended with the following function:
One such system is the XT Control by Valmet, an automated hood exhaust air humidity and hood air balance control system which monitors and optimizes the hood's zero-pressure line.
A principal control parameter of this system is the hood exhaust air humidity set point which varies according to hood exhaust air temperature as seen below:
The zero-level measurement is done with special sampling ports and temperature sensors.
A case example at Guangzhou PM9 in China combined this system with a full scope blow-box upgrade which had the goal of optimizing dryer section ventilation. The result was an energy savings of 500 kW in electricity. Hood air balance improved with a reduction in total hood exhaust volume and reduced spill into the machine room. An energy savings of 500 kW in electricity produced an annual savings of $200,000/yr for a return on investment period of 4 months.
In the reference period between 2010 and 2020, Valmet supplied 50 hood deliveries of which 45 had complete XT Control systems. In 2018 alone, 8 start-ups of OptiAir Hoods all had XT Control, not considering all the rebuilds which also included XT Control Systems.
For the savings to be sustainable, the flow meters and humidity sensors must be adequately maintained for proper calibration. A regular inspection strategy is required to upkeep the equipment, such as sending units back to the OEM for recalibration every 6 months. Without annual or semi-annual maintenance, it would be difficult to know how long such units could be accurate in measurement and automatic control. In the event of an instrument being off calibration, the system can be operated in remote manual control during the interim period while the recalibration work is conducted.
In summary, the factors affecting the energy savings in the dryer section are:
In conclusion, these parameters can be addressed in a systematic way by breaking down the optimization work into the following 3 phases:
1) Know where you are:
2) Optimize performance:
3) Follow and monitor:
To help facilitate the process, energy efficiency improvements can be done progressively to reduce your energy footprint step-by-step.
For more information on optimizing your air systems performance, watch the recorded webinar by clicking HERE or on the WEBINAR link, or contact your Valmet representative.